ALL ABOUT MODULUS OF SUBGRADE REACTION

Modulus of Subgrade Reaction is an important soil parameter used in Structural and Geotechnical Engineering. It is used in conjunction with a soils allowable bearing capacity to design footings and rigid pavements. So what exactly is the Modulus of Subgrade Reaction?…

The Modulus of Subgrade Reaction is a measure of a soils stiffness. It is an indicator of a soils resultant unit displacement under a given pressure. The units of Modulus of Subgrade Reaction are often expressed as kPa/mm, MPa/mm or pci (kilopascal per millimetre, megapascal per millimetre and pound per cubic inch respectively). It is also often referred to as soil spring stiffness and is used by Structural Engineers as part of their analysis to predict a footing or pavements settlement under a given design loading. The higher the Modulus of Subgrade, the stiffer the soil is.

Soil Stiffness Equation

The Modulus of subgrade is simply a unit displacement of soil under a given applied pressure. This is represented by the equation below…

Modulus of Subgrade Equation (also known as soil spring stiffness)

This soil stiffness property “k” is determined using fiend testing (covered later in this article).

What are the Units for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction

There are quite a number of units which are used to express the Modulus of Subgrade Reaction and this can get rather confusing.

Re-visiting the introduction to this article for the explanation of soil spring stiffness helps us to better understand its units… “a measure of a soils unit displacement under a given pressure”. Lets now take a look at an example soil spring stiffness value and un-pack it a little further…

Example value and associated unit for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction
Example value and associated unit for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction

This is a soil stiffness for a weak clay material given as 12,000kPa/mm. In real terms this means that for every 12,000kPa applied to the soil (kilonewton per meter squared), the soil is expected to displace or settle 1mm.

You may also see this soil property expressed in other units such as kN/m3 or N/mm3 (kilonewton per cubic metre or newton per cubic millimetre respectively). This can further complicate the matter however MPa/mm is exactly the same as N/mm3. This is because MPa/mm is essentially the same as N/mm2/mm which is the same as N/mm3. The next section of this article provides a handy unit conversion table for your reference…

Unit Conversion for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction

Here are some common units used for soil spring stiffness with their respective unit conversions…

UNITEQUIVALENT UNIT
1 kPA/mm0.001 MPa/mm
1 kPa/m0.0000001 MPa/mm
1 kPa/mm1000 kPa/m
1 MPa/mm1000 kPa/mm
1 MPa/mm1000000 kPa/m
1 Mpa/mm1000 MPa/m
1 kPa/m1 kN/m3
1 MPa/mm1 N/mm3
1 kPa/m0.0037pci (lb/in3)
1 MPa/m3.68pci (lb/in3)
Unit conversion for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction (Soil Spring Stiffness)

What are the Expected Values for Modulus of Subgrade Reaction

The value for soil spring stiffness is acquired by site testing performed by a qualified Geotechnical Engineer.

As a general guide however, here are some ranges of values you can expect for different soil conditions…

Soil TypeModulus of Subgrade (kPa/m)Modulus of Subgrade (MPa/mm)
Compacted Sand50,000 – 150,0000.05 – 0.15
Clay80,000 – 100,0000.08 – 0.10
Crushed Stone100,000 – 150,0000.10 – 0.15
Corse Crushed Stone200,000 – 250,0000.20 – 0.25
Ranges of Modulus of Subgrade for different Soil Types

How is the Modulus of Subgrade Reaction used in Footing Design

The Modulus of Subgrade is an important factor in the design of footings and rigid pavements.

Structural Engineers use this soil stiffness parameter for footings which are sensitive to movement or supporting critical infrastructure.

The soil stiffness properties are often modelled in an FEA design software along with the footing itself. The modelling of this support condition is usually simplified by a series of point spring supports or depending on the software a spring area support. For a step-by-step example of this process, take a look at THIS article where I perform this check on a strip footing using RAM Concept.

A change in soil stiffness can drastically alter the distribution of the resultant pressure applied from the footing to the soil. The deign of critical foundations involves a collaboration between both the Structural and Geotechnical engineers. The example below shows two isolated pad footings which are identical both in dimensions and applied loading however the footing on the right has twice the soil stiffness as the footing on the left. As you can see, the stress distribution is quite different not only in shape but magnitude when comparing the two…

Plan view of two identical isolated pad footings with the only exception being the footing on the right has double the soil stiffness compared to the one on the left.  notice the drastic difference in stress distribution an peak magnitude (values are in kilopascals or kPa).
Plan view of two identical isolated pad footings with the only exception being the footing on the right has double the soil stiffness compared to the one on the left. notice the drastic difference in stress distribution an peak magnitude (values are in kilopascals or kPa).

How is Soil Stiffness Determined or Measured?

The Modulus of Subgrade Reaction is determined using a field plate load test. The plate load test is performed to determine the ultimate bearing capacity of the soil and the probable settlement under the given load. This test type is often used to determine soil capacities and stiffness’s for shallow footing systems.

A stiff plate (usually steel) is placed on the proposed soil at a given founding depth. This often requires the digging of a trench to the proposed founding depth of the proposed future footings. A load is then gradually applied to the plate and the settlement is recorded at each incremental load increase. This is somewhat similar to how deep pile foundations are tested for strength and serviceability (for more information on how foundation piles are tested in the field take a look at THIS article).

When the soil begins to “fail” during this field test, exponentially higher settlements are recorded for the same given load incremental increase. The total load applied to the plate at the beginning of this exponential increase is recorded and the magnitude is divided by the area of the plate. This value represents the soils ultimate bearing capacity. A safety factor is then applied to this value to obtain the safe bearing capacity (usually a safety factor anywhere from 2 to 3).

Image of a plate load test set-up. This is a field test performed on soil to determine its bearing capacity as well as soil stiffness. (Source: CMR Technical Services)
Published by:

Quentin Suckling is our founding director.  Prior to starting Sheer Force Engineering, he spent almost 2 decades working as a practicing Structural Engineer at Tier 1 engineering consulting firms delivering multiple billions of dollars worth of projects and managing large multi-disciplinary engineering teams. View More Posts

Follow Blog via Email

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 180 other subscribers

Need a Structural Engineer?

Empower your structures with the precision of Sheer Force Engineering. Our commitment to excellence in structural design and analysis ensures unparalleled stability and durability. Whether you’re embarking on a new project or seeking to enhance an existing structure, partner with us for innovative solutions and unwavering expertise. Let Sheer Force Engineering be the driving force behind your architectural aspirations. Contact us today to transform your visions into resilient realities – where strength meets precision, and excellence becomes a lasting legacy

Discover more from Sheer Force Engineering

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading